People are still responding to my post on the simple gospel Richard explains himself very well and makes it quite clear that he doesnt believe Jesus took the punishment for our sin instead of us. What I want to know from my mainstream evangelical blogger friends is this: am I right to doubt that such a belief system is compatible with mainstream evangelicalism?

Meanwhile Bob is exploring it from a philosophical perspective

• Another statement of the simple gospel
• Preaching the simple gospel: Have you got Beautiful feet?
• The ‘Simple Gospel’ Discussion Continues
• How not to preach the simple gospel
• Why I love a Simple Gospel
• More on the simple gospel- what actually saves us
• The simple gospel debate continues…..
• The Simple Gospel: Restated
• The simple gospel saves marriages
• The Simple Gospel debate continues
• Preaching to the converted, the simple gospel and alpha
• The simple gospel according to John Piper- Did Christ Die for Us or for God?
• The simple gospel: Justification by Faith by John Calvin
• The Simple Gospel discussion continues : God made us for love which we reject
• Do not deny the wrath of God or you deny the simple gospel